ESAPD | | | 78.19 1 | 83.74 1 | 71.72 1 | 79.01 1 | 81.38 1 | 83.23 2 | 58.63 2 | 83.92 5 | 62.44 12 | 87.06 2 | 85.82 1 | 64.54 3 | 79.39 5 | 77.99 8 | 82.44 17 | 90.61 1 |
|
APDe-MVS | | | 77.58 2 | 82.93 2 | 71.35 2 | 77.86 2 | 80.55 2 | 83.38 1 | 57.61 7 | 85.57 1 | 61.11 15 | 86.10 4 | 82.98 4 | 64.76 2 | 78.29 12 | 76.78 19 | 83.40 6 | 90.20 2 |
|
SteuartSystems-ACMMP | | | 75.23 9 | 79.60 11 | 70.13 9 | 76.81 3 | 78.92 8 | 81.74 4 | 57.99 5 | 75.30 25 | 59.83 21 | 75.69 14 | 78.45 19 | 60.48 25 | 80.58 2 | 79.77 2 | 83.94 3 | 88.52 6 |
Skip Steuart: Steuart Systems R&D Blog. |
HPM-MVS++ | | | 76.01 6 | 80.47 8 | 70.81 4 | 76.60 4 | 74.96 31 | 80.18 12 | 58.36 4 | 81.96 6 | 63.50 7 | 78.80 10 | 82.53 7 | 64.40 4 | 78.74 8 | 78.84 5 | 81.81 27 | 87.46 13 |
|
MCST-MVS | | | 73.67 21 | 77.39 22 | 69.33 15 | 76.26 5 | 78.19 13 | 78.77 21 | 54.54 25 | 75.33 23 | 59.99 20 | 67.96 28 | 79.23 17 | 62.43 13 | 78.00 16 | 75.71 26 | 84.02 2 | 87.30 14 |
|
CNVR-MVS | | | 75.62 8 | 79.91 10 | 70.61 5 | 75.76 6 | 78.82 10 | 81.66 5 | 57.12 9 | 79.77 13 | 63.04 8 | 70.69 20 | 81.15 10 | 62.99 8 | 80.23 3 | 79.54 3 | 83.11 7 | 89.16 4 |
|
NCCC | | | 74.27 15 | 77.83 21 | 70.13 9 | 75.70 7 | 77.41 18 | 80.51 10 | 57.09 10 | 78.25 17 | 62.28 13 | 65.54 33 | 78.26 20 | 62.18 15 | 79.13 6 | 78.51 6 | 83.01 9 | 87.68 12 |
|
CSCG | | | 74.68 12 | 79.22 12 | 69.40 14 | 75.69 8 | 80.01 5 | 79.12 19 | 52.83 36 | 79.34 14 | 63.99 4 | 70.49 21 | 82.02 8 | 60.35 27 | 77.48 22 | 77.22 16 | 84.38 1 | 87.97 11 |
|
APD-MVS | | | 75.80 7 | 80.90 7 | 69.86 12 | 75.42 9 | 78.48 12 | 81.43 7 | 57.44 8 | 80.45 11 | 59.32 22 | 85.28 5 | 80.82 12 | 63.96 5 | 76.89 25 | 76.08 24 | 81.58 33 | 88.30 8 |
Yuesong Wang, Zhaojie Zeng and etc.: Adaptive Patch Deformation for Textureless-Resilient Multi-View Stereo. CVPR2023 |
SMA-MVS | | | 77.34 3 | 82.65 3 | 71.13 3 | 75.33 10 | 80.39 3 | 82.14 3 | 58.49 3 | 84.51 4 | 63.89 5 | 78.09 11 | 83.76 2 | 63.31 7 | 81.19 1 | 80.62 1 | 83.60 4 | 90.03 3 |
|
HSP-MVS | | | 76.78 4 | 82.44 4 | 70.19 8 | 75.26 11 | 80.22 4 | 80.59 8 | 57.85 6 | 84.79 3 | 60.84 16 | 88.54 1 | 83.43 3 | 66.24 1 | 78.21 15 | 76.47 21 | 80.34 39 | 85.43 27 |
|
train_agg | | | 73.89 18 | 78.25 18 | 68.80 19 | 75.25 12 | 72.27 47 | 79.75 13 | 56.05 17 | 74.87 28 | 58.97 23 | 81.83 7 | 79.76 16 | 61.05 22 | 77.39 23 | 76.01 25 | 81.71 30 | 85.61 25 |
|
TSAR-MVS + MP. | | | 75.22 10 | 80.06 9 | 69.56 13 | 74.61 13 | 72.74 45 | 80.59 8 | 55.70 20 | 80.80 9 | 62.65 10 | 86.25 3 | 82.92 5 | 62.07 16 | 76.89 25 | 75.66 27 | 81.77 29 | 85.19 29 |
|
SD-MVS | | | 74.43 13 | 78.87 14 | 69.26 16 | 74.39 14 | 73.70 41 | 79.06 20 | 55.24 22 | 81.04 8 | 62.71 9 | 80.18 8 | 82.61 6 | 61.70 18 | 75.43 36 | 73.92 39 | 82.44 17 | 85.22 28 |
|
ACMMP_Plus | | | 76.15 5 | 81.17 5 | 70.30 6 | 74.09 15 | 79.47 6 | 81.59 6 | 57.09 10 | 81.38 7 | 63.89 5 | 79.02 9 | 80.48 13 | 62.24 14 | 80.05 4 | 79.12 4 | 82.94 10 | 88.64 5 |
|
HFP-MVS | | | 74.87 11 | 78.86 16 | 70.21 7 | 73.99 16 | 77.91 14 | 80.36 11 | 56.63 12 | 78.41 16 | 64.27 3 | 74.54 16 | 77.75 23 | 62.96 9 | 78.70 9 | 77.82 10 | 83.02 8 | 86.91 16 |
|
AdaColmap | | | 67.89 42 | 68.85 52 | 66.77 25 | 73.73 17 | 74.30 38 | 75.28 36 | 53.58 31 | 70.24 41 | 57.59 30 | 51.19 84 | 59.19 77 | 60.74 24 | 75.33 38 | 73.72 41 | 79.69 46 | 77.96 61 |
|
MP-MVS | | | 74.31 14 | 78.87 14 | 68.99 17 | 73.49 18 | 78.56 11 | 79.25 18 | 56.51 13 | 75.33 23 | 60.69 18 | 75.30 15 | 79.12 18 | 61.81 17 | 77.78 19 | 77.93 9 | 82.18 23 | 88.06 10 |
Rongxuan Tan, Qing Wang, et al.: MP-MVS: Multi-Scale Windows PatchMatch and Planar Prior Multi-View Stereo. |
zzz-MVS | | | 74.25 16 | 77.97 20 | 69.91 11 | 73.43 19 | 74.06 39 | 79.69 14 | 56.44 14 | 80.74 10 | 64.98 2 | 68.72 26 | 79.98 15 | 62.92 10 | 78.24 14 | 77.77 12 | 81.99 25 | 86.30 18 |
|
TSAR-MVS + ACMM | | | 72.56 24 | 79.07 13 | 64.96 36 | 73.24 20 | 73.16 44 | 78.50 22 | 48.80 60 | 79.34 14 | 55.32 36 | 85.04 6 | 81.49 9 | 58.57 34 | 75.06 40 | 73.75 40 | 75.35 104 | 85.61 25 |
|
CDPH-MVS | | | 71.47 27 | 75.82 27 | 66.41 27 | 72.97 21 | 77.15 20 | 78.14 25 | 54.71 23 | 69.88 44 | 53.07 52 | 70.98 19 | 74.83 31 | 56.95 45 | 76.22 29 | 76.57 20 | 82.62 15 | 85.09 30 |
|
PGM-MVS | | | 72.89 22 | 77.13 23 | 67.94 21 | 72.47 22 | 77.25 19 | 79.27 17 | 54.63 24 | 73.71 30 | 57.95 29 | 72.38 18 | 75.33 29 | 60.75 23 | 78.25 13 | 77.36 15 | 82.57 16 | 85.62 24 |
|
ACMMPR | | | 73.79 20 | 78.41 17 | 68.40 20 | 72.35 23 | 77.79 15 | 79.32 16 | 56.38 15 | 77.67 20 | 58.30 27 | 74.16 17 | 76.66 24 | 61.40 19 | 78.32 11 | 77.80 11 | 82.68 14 | 86.51 17 |
|
OPM-MVS | | | 69.33 33 | 71.05 42 | 67.32 23 | 72.34 24 | 75.70 28 | 79.57 15 | 56.34 16 | 55.21 65 | 53.81 49 | 59.51 54 | 68.96 48 | 59.67 30 | 77.61 21 | 76.44 22 | 82.19 22 | 83.88 36 |
|
X-MVS | | | 71.18 28 | 75.66 28 | 65.96 31 | 71.71 25 | 76.96 21 | 77.26 28 | 55.88 19 | 72.75 33 | 54.48 44 | 64.39 38 | 74.47 32 | 54.19 57 | 77.84 18 | 77.37 14 | 82.21 21 | 85.85 22 |
|
HQP-MVS | | | 70.88 29 | 75.02 29 | 66.05 30 | 71.69 26 | 74.47 36 | 77.51 27 | 53.17 33 | 72.89 32 | 54.88 40 | 70.03 23 | 70.48 45 | 57.26 41 | 76.02 31 | 75.01 31 | 81.78 28 | 86.21 19 |
|
MAR-MVS | | | 68.04 41 | 70.74 44 | 64.90 38 | 71.68 27 | 76.33 26 | 74.63 40 | 50.48 50 | 63.81 52 | 55.52 35 | 54.88 70 | 69.90 47 | 57.39 40 | 75.42 37 | 74.79 33 | 79.71 43 | 80.03 51 |
Zhenyu Xu, Yiguang Liu, Xuelei Shi, Ying Wang, Yunan Zheng: MARMVS: Matching Ambiguity Reduced Multiple View Stereo for Efficient Large Scale Scene Reconstruction. CVPR 2020 |
mPP-MVS | | | | | | 71.67 28 | | | | | | | 74.36 35 | | | | | |
|
CLD-MVS | | | 67.02 46 | 71.57 39 | 61.71 48 | 71.01 29 | 74.81 33 | 71.62 48 | 38.91 168 | 71.86 36 | 60.70 17 | 64.97 36 | 67.88 54 | 51.88 95 | 76.77 28 | 74.98 32 | 76.11 96 | 69.75 121 |
Zhaoxin Li, Wangmeng Zuo, Zhaoqi Wang, Lei Zhang: Confidence-based Large-scale Dense Multi-view Stereo. IEEE Transaction on Image Processing, 2020 |
CP-MVS | | | 72.63 23 | 76.95 24 | 67.59 22 | 70.67 30 | 75.53 29 | 77.95 26 | 56.01 18 | 75.65 22 | 58.82 24 | 69.16 25 | 76.48 25 | 60.46 26 | 77.66 20 | 77.20 17 | 81.65 31 | 86.97 15 |
|
ACMM | | 60.30 7 | 67.58 44 | 68.82 53 | 66.13 29 | 70.59 31 | 72.01 49 | 76.54 30 | 54.26 27 | 65.64 50 | 54.78 42 | 50.35 86 | 61.72 68 | 58.74 33 | 75.79 34 | 75.03 29 | 81.88 26 | 81.17 48 |
Qingshan Xu and Wenbing Tao: Multi-Scale Geometric Consistency Guided Multi-View Stereo. CVPR 2019 |
XVS | | | | | | 70.49 32 | 76.96 21 | 74.36 41 | | | 54.48 44 | | 74.47 32 | | | | 82.24 19 | |
|
X-MVStestdata | | | | | | 70.49 32 | 76.96 21 | 74.36 41 | | | 54.48 44 | | 74.47 32 | | | | 82.24 19 | |
|
ACMMP | | | 71.57 26 | 75.84 26 | 66.59 26 | 70.30 34 | 76.85 24 | 78.46 23 | 53.95 29 | 73.52 31 | 55.56 34 | 70.13 22 | 71.36 43 | 58.55 35 | 77.00 24 | 76.23 23 | 82.71 13 | 85.81 23 |
Qingshan Xu, Weihang Kong, Wenbing Tao, Marc Pollefeys: Multi-Scale Geometric Consistency Guided and Planar Prior Assisted Multi-View Stereo. IEEE Transactions on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence |
abl_6 | | | | | 64.36 41 | 70.08 35 | 77.45 17 | 72.88 46 | 50.15 51 | 71.31 38 | 54.77 43 | 62.79 42 | 77.99 22 | 56.80 46 | | | 81.50 34 | 83.91 35 |
|
MVS_111021_HR | | | 67.62 43 | 70.39 46 | 64.39 40 | 69.77 36 | 70.45 54 | 71.44 50 | 51.72 42 | 60.77 59 | 55.06 38 | 62.14 47 | 66.40 57 | 58.13 37 | 76.13 30 | 74.79 33 | 80.19 41 | 82.04 45 |
|
MSLP-MVS++ | | | 68.17 40 | 70.72 45 | 65.19 34 | 69.41 37 | 70.64 52 | 74.99 37 | 45.76 69 | 70.20 42 | 60.17 19 | 56.42 63 | 73.01 38 | 61.14 20 | 72.80 48 | 70.54 52 | 79.70 44 | 81.42 47 |
|
LGP-MVS_train | | | 68.87 36 | 72.03 38 | 65.18 35 | 69.33 38 | 74.03 40 | 76.67 29 | 53.88 30 | 68.46 45 | 52.05 55 | 63.21 40 | 63.89 60 | 56.31 47 | 75.99 32 | 74.43 35 | 82.83 12 | 84.18 32 |
|
ACMP | | 61.42 5 | 68.72 39 | 71.37 40 | 65.64 33 | 69.06 39 | 74.45 37 | 75.88 34 | 53.30 32 | 68.10 46 | 55.74 33 | 61.53 50 | 62.29 65 | 56.97 44 | 74.70 41 | 74.23 37 | 82.88 11 | 84.31 31 |
Qingshan Xu and Wenbing Tao: Planar Prior Assisted PatchMatch Multi-View Stereo. AAAI 2020 |
DeepC-MVS_fast | | 65.08 3 | 72.00 25 | 76.11 25 | 67.21 24 | 68.93 40 | 77.46 16 | 76.54 30 | 54.35 26 | 74.92 27 | 58.64 26 | 65.18 35 | 74.04 37 | 62.62 11 | 77.92 17 | 77.02 18 | 82.16 24 | 86.21 19 |
Andreas Kuhn, Christian Sormann, Mattia Rossi, Oliver Erdler, Friedrich Fraundorfer: DeepC-MVS: Deep Confidence Prediction for Multi-View Stereo Reconstruction. 3DV 2020 |
casdiffmvs | | | 69.26 35 | 72.98 35 | 64.92 37 | 68.82 41 | 71.44 50 | 75.94 33 | 49.64 53 | 70.13 43 | 53.48 51 | 65.33 34 | 72.95 39 | 60.21 28 | 75.33 38 | 72.90 45 | 81.41 35 | 82.78 41 |
|
CANet | | | 68.77 37 | 73.01 33 | 63.83 43 | 68.30 42 | 75.19 30 | 73.73 44 | 47.90 61 | 63.86 51 | 54.84 41 | 67.51 30 | 74.36 35 | 57.62 38 | 74.22 43 | 73.57 43 | 80.56 38 | 82.36 42 |
|
TSAR-MVS + GP. | | | 69.71 30 | 73.92 32 | 64.80 39 | 68.27 43 | 70.56 53 | 71.90 47 | 50.75 46 | 71.38 37 | 57.46 31 | 68.68 27 | 75.42 28 | 60.10 29 | 73.47 45 | 73.99 38 | 80.32 40 | 83.97 34 |
|
3Dnovator+ | | 62.63 4 | 69.51 31 | 72.62 36 | 65.88 32 | 68.21 44 | 76.47 25 | 73.50 45 | 52.74 37 | 70.85 39 | 58.65 25 | 55.97 65 | 69.95 46 | 61.11 21 | 76.80 27 | 75.09 28 | 81.09 37 | 83.23 40 |
|
MVS_0304 | | | 69.49 32 | 73.96 31 | 64.28 42 | 67.92 45 | 76.13 27 | 74.90 38 | 47.60 62 | 63.29 54 | 54.09 48 | 67.44 31 | 76.35 26 | 59.53 31 | 75.81 33 | 75.03 29 | 81.62 32 | 83.70 37 |
|
DeepC-MVS | | 66.32 2 | 73.85 19 | 78.10 19 | 68.90 18 | 67.92 45 | 79.31 7 | 78.16 24 | 59.28 1 | 78.24 18 | 61.13 14 | 67.36 32 | 76.10 27 | 63.40 6 | 79.11 7 | 78.41 7 | 83.52 5 | 88.16 9 |
Andreas Kuhn, Christian Sormann, Mattia Rossi, Oliver Erdler, Friedrich Fraundorfer: DeepC-MVS: Deep Confidence Prediction for Multi-View Stereo Reconstruction. 3DV 2020 |
DeepPCF-MVS | | 66.49 1 | 74.25 16 | 80.97 6 | 66.41 27 | 67.75 47 | 78.87 9 | 75.61 35 | 54.16 28 | 84.86 2 | 58.22 28 | 77.94 12 | 81.01 11 | 62.52 12 | 78.34 10 | 77.38 13 | 80.16 42 | 88.40 7 |
|
UA-Net | | | 58.50 87 | 64.68 67 | 51.30 119 | 66.97 48 | 67.13 74 | 53.68 160 | 45.65 72 | 49.51 90 | 31.58 147 | 62.91 41 | 68.47 50 | 35.85 169 | 68.20 82 | 67.28 77 | 74.03 113 | 69.24 131 |
|
PHI-MVS | | | 69.27 34 | 74.84 30 | 62.76 47 | 66.83 49 | 74.83 32 | 73.88 43 | 49.32 56 | 70.61 40 | 50.93 56 | 69.62 24 | 74.84 30 | 57.25 42 | 75.53 35 | 74.32 36 | 78.35 56 | 84.17 33 |
|
3Dnovator | | 60.86 6 | 66.99 47 | 70.32 47 | 63.11 45 | 66.63 50 | 74.52 34 | 71.56 49 | 45.76 69 | 67.37 48 | 55.00 39 | 54.31 74 | 68.19 52 | 58.49 36 | 73.97 44 | 73.63 42 | 81.22 36 | 80.23 50 |
|
EPNet | | | 65.14 52 | 69.54 50 | 60.00 52 | 66.61 51 | 67.67 67 | 67.53 56 | 55.32 21 | 62.67 56 | 46.22 72 | 67.74 29 | 65.93 58 | 48.07 111 | 72.17 50 | 72.12 46 | 76.28 88 | 78.47 58 |
Wanjuan Su, Wenbing Tao: Efficient Edge-Preserving Multi-View Stereo Network for Depth Estimation. AAAI 2023 |
OpenMVS | | 57.13 9 | 62.81 56 | 65.75 60 | 59.39 54 | 66.47 52 | 69.52 56 | 64.26 101 | 43.07 123 | 61.34 58 | 50.19 59 | 47.29 120 | 64.41 59 | 54.60 56 | 70.18 64 | 68.62 67 | 77.73 58 | 78.89 55 |
|
ACMH | | 52.42 13 | 58.24 98 | 59.56 111 | 56.70 89 | 66.34 53 | 69.59 55 | 66.71 72 | 49.12 57 | 46.08 127 | 28.90 160 | 42.67 169 | 41.20 188 | 52.60 85 | 71.39 54 | 70.28 54 | 76.51 83 | 75.72 81 |
Qingshan Xu and Wenbing Tao: Multi-Scale Geometric Consistency Guided Multi-View Stereo. CVPR 2019 |
MSDG | | | 58.46 89 | 58.97 118 | 57.85 66 | 66.27 54 | 66.23 82 | 67.72 54 | 42.33 139 | 53.43 72 | 43.68 97 | 43.39 155 | 45.35 156 | 49.75 101 | 68.66 73 | 67.77 72 | 77.38 64 | 67.96 135 |
|
QAPM | | | 65.27 50 | 69.49 51 | 60.35 50 | 65.43 55 | 72.20 48 | 65.69 90 | 47.23 64 | 63.46 53 | 49.14 61 | 53.56 75 | 71.04 44 | 57.01 43 | 72.60 49 | 71.41 49 | 77.62 60 | 82.14 44 |
|
CPTT-MVS | | | 68.76 38 | 73.01 33 | 63.81 44 | 65.42 56 | 73.66 42 | 76.39 32 | 52.08 38 | 72.61 34 | 50.33 58 | 60.73 51 | 72.65 41 | 59.43 32 | 73.32 46 | 72.12 46 | 79.19 50 | 85.99 21 |
|
MS-PatchMatch | | | 58.19 100 | 60.20 91 | 55.85 94 | 65.17 57 | 64.16 101 | 64.82 95 | 41.48 150 | 50.95 82 | 42.17 106 | 45.38 140 | 56.42 87 | 48.08 110 | 68.30 78 | 66.70 84 | 73.39 121 | 69.46 129 |
|
PCF-MVS | | 59.98 8 | 67.32 45 | 71.04 43 | 62.97 46 | 64.77 58 | 74.49 35 | 74.78 39 | 49.54 54 | 67.44 47 | 54.39 47 | 58.35 58 | 72.81 40 | 55.79 53 | 71.54 53 | 69.24 60 | 78.57 52 | 83.41 38 |
Andreas Kuhn, Shan Lin, Oliver Erdler: Plane Completion and Filtering for Multi-View Stereo Reconstruction. GCPR 2019 |
EG-PatchMatch MVS | | | 56.98 107 | 58.24 124 | 55.50 96 | 64.66 59 | 68.62 59 | 61.48 110 | 43.63 106 | 38.44 199 | 41.44 108 | 38.05 191 | 46.18 153 | 43.95 128 | 71.71 52 | 70.61 51 | 77.87 57 | 74.08 107 |
|
Effi-MVS+-dtu | | | 60.34 65 | 62.32 74 | 58.03 61 | 64.31 60 | 67.44 70 | 65.99 86 | 42.26 140 | 49.55 88 | 42.00 107 | 48.92 98 | 59.79 75 | 56.27 48 | 68.07 88 | 67.03 78 | 77.35 65 | 75.45 84 |
|
FC-MVSNet-train | | | 58.40 95 | 63.15 72 | 52.85 111 | 64.29 61 | 61.84 121 | 55.98 141 | 46.47 65 | 53.06 75 | 34.96 134 | 61.95 49 | 56.37 89 | 39.49 147 | 68.67 72 | 68.36 68 | 75.92 101 | 71.81 110 |
|
Effi-MVS+ | | | 63.28 54 | 65.96 59 | 60.17 51 | 64.26 62 | 68.06 62 | 68.78 53 | 45.71 71 | 54.08 69 | 46.64 68 | 55.92 66 | 63.13 63 | 55.94 51 | 70.38 62 | 71.43 48 | 79.68 47 | 78.70 56 |
|
LS3D | | | 60.20 66 | 61.70 75 | 58.45 57 | 64.18 63 | 67.77 64 | 67.19 58 | 48.84 59 | 61.67 57 | 41.27 110 | 45.89 134 | 51.81 117 | 54.18 58 | 68.78 70 | 66.50 91 | 75.03 105 | 69.48 127 |
|
ACMH+ | | 53.71 12 | 59.26 69 | 60.28 88 | 58.06 59 | 64.17 64 | 68.46 60 | 67.51 57 | 50.93 45 | 52.46 79 | 35.83 131 | 40.83 181 | 45.12 159 | 52.32 91 | 69.88 65 | 69.00 63 | 77.59 62 | 76.21 79 |
|
DELS-MVS | | | 65.87 48 | 70.30 48 | 60.71 49 | 64.05 65 | 72.68 46 | 70.90 51 | 45.43 73 | 57.49 62 | 49.05 62 | 64.43 37 | 68.66 49 | 55.11 55 | 74.31 42 | 73.02 44 | 79.70 44 | 81.51 46 |
Christian Sormann, Emanuele Santellani, Mattia Rossi, Andreas Kuhn, Friedrich Fraundorfer: DELS-MVS: Deep Epipolar Line Search for Multi-View Stereo. Winter Conference on Applications of Computer Vision (WACV), 2023 |
canonicalmvs | | | 65.62 49 | 72.06 37 | 58.11 58 | 63.94 66 | 71.05 51 | 64.49 99 | 43.18 118 | 74.08 29 | 47.35 65 | 64.17 39 | 71.97 42 | 51.17 98 | 71.87 51 | 70.74 50 | 78.51 54 | 80.56 49 |
|
Anonymous20240521 | | | 56.75 112 | 60.48 86 | 52.38 115 | 63.71 67 | 63.79 103 | 58.12 124 | 47.59 63 | 53.88 70 | 33.16 138 | 45.79 136 | 57.11 85 | 39.99 146 | 68.59 74 | 66.26 93 | 71.74 153 | 67.97 134 |
|
tpmp4_e23 | | | 56.84 111 | 57.14 131 | 56.49 92 | 62.45 68 | 62.05 119 | 67.57 55 | 41.56 148 | 54.17 68 | 48.57 64 | 49.18 90 | 46.54 149 | 50.44 100 | 61.93 166 | 58.82 180 | 68.34 173 | 67.28 140 |
|
gg-mvs-nofinetune | | | 49.07 169 | 52.56 168 | 45.00 170 | 61.99 69 | 59.78 145 | 53.55 163 | 41.63 144 | 31.62 216 | 12.08 213 | 29.56 209 | 53.28 98 | 29.57 189 | 66.27 131 | 64.49 136 | 71.19 157 | 62.92 175 |
|
IS_MVSNet | | | 57.95 102 | 64.26 69 | 50.60 121 | 61.62 70 | 65.25 95 | 57.18 130 | 45.42 74 | 50.79 83 | 26.49 174 | 57.81 60 | 60.05 74 | 34.51 173 | 71.24 57 | 70.20 56 | 78.36 55 | 74.44 100 |
|
NR-MVSNet | | | 55.35 121 | 59.46 113 | 50.56 122 | 61.33 71 | 62.97 115 | 57.91 127 | 51.80 40 | 48.62 105 | 20.59 192 | 51.99 81 | 44.73 167 | 34.10 176 | 68.58 75 | 68.64 66 | 77.66 59 | 70.67 118 |
|
MVS_111021_LR | | | 63.05 55 | 66.43 56 | 59.10 55 | 61.33 71 | 63.77 104 | 65.87 88 | 43.58 107 | 60.20 60 | 53.70 50 | 62.09 48 | 62.38 64 | 55.84 52 | 70.24 63 | 68.08 69 | 74.30 109 | 78.28 60 |
|
EPP-MVSNet | | | 59.39 68 | 65.45 62 | 52.32 116 | 60.96 73 | 67.70 66 | 58.42 123 | 44.75 80 | 49.71 87 | 27.23 172 | 59.03 55 | 62.20 66 | 43.34 133 | 70.71 59 | 69.13 61 | 79.25 49 | 79.63 53 |
|
TransMVSNet (Re) | | | 51.92 148 | 55.38 141 | 47.88 154 | 60.95 74 | 59.90 143 | 53.95 157 | 45.14 76 | 39.47 190 | 24.85 180 | 43.87 150 | 46.51 150 | 29.15 190 | 67.55 103 | 65.23 125 | 73.26 125 | 65.16 164 |
|
gm-plane-assit | | | 44.74 195 | 45.95 202 | 43.33 181 | 60.88 75 | 46.79 209 | 36.97 218 | 32.24 210 | 24.15 227 | 11.79 214 | 29.26 212 | 32.97 214 | 46.64 118 | 65.09 148 | 62.95 154 | 71.45 155 | 60.42 186 |
|
DI_MVS_plusplus_trai | | | 61.88 60 | 65.17 64 | 58.06 59 | 60.05 76 | 65.26 94 | 66.03 85 | 44.22 85 | 55.75 64 | 46.73 67 | 54.64 72 | 68.12 53 | 54.13 59 | 69.13 68 | 66.66 85 | 77.18 66 | 76.61 71 |
|
PVSNet_Blended_VisFu | | | 63.65 53 | 66.92 54 | 59.83 53 | 60.03 77 | 73.44 43 | 66.33 81 | 48.95 58 | 52.20 80 | 50.81 57 | 56.07 64 | 60.25 73 | 53.56 62 | 73.23 47 | 70.01 57 | 79.30 48 | 83.24 39 |
|
UniMVSNet_NR-MVSNet | | | 56.94 109 | 61.14 77 | 52.05 118 | 60.02 78 | 65.21 96 | 57.44 128 | 52.93 35 | 49.37 91 | 24.31 183 | 54.62 73 | 50.54 124 | 39.04 149 | 68.69 71 | 68.84 64 | 78.53 53 | 70.72 114 |
|
IterMVS-LS | | | 58.30 97 | 61.39 76 | 54.71 99 | 59.92 79 | 58.40 161 | 59.42 120 | 43.64 104 | 48.71 101 | 40.25 114 | 57.53 61 | 58.55 79 | 52.15 93 | 65.42 146 | 65.34 122 | 72.85 128 | 75.77 80 |
Fangjinhua Wang, Silvano Galliani, Christoph Vogel, Marc Pollefeys: IterMVS: Iterative Probability Estimation for Efficient Multi-View Stereo. |
MVS_Test | | | 62.40 59 | 66.23 58 | 57.94 62 | 59.77 80 | 64.77 99 | 66.50 80 | 41.76 143 | 57.26 63 | 49.33 60 | 62.68 44 | 67.47 56 | 53.50 65 | 68.57 76 | 66.25 94 | 76.77 73 | 76.58 73 |
|
TranMVSNet+NR-MVSNet | | | 55.87 115 | 60.14 96 | 50.88 120 | 59.46 81 | 63.82 102 | 57.93 126 | 52.98 34 | 48.94 96 | 20.52 193 | 52.87 77 | 47.33 140 | 36.81 166 | 69.12 69 | 69.03 62 | 77.56 63 | 69.89 120 |
|
Fast-Effi-MVS+ | | | 60.36 64 | 63.35 71 | 56.87 84 | 58.70 82 | 65.86 90 | 65.08 94 | 37.11 181 | 53.00 77 | 45.36 81 | 52.12 80 | 56.07 91 | 56.27 48 | 71.28 56 | 69.42 59 | 78.71 51 | 75.69 82 |
|
IB-MVS | | 54.11 11 | 58.36 96 | 60.70 79 | 55.62 95 | 58.67 83 | 68.02 63 | 61.56 108 | 43.15 119 | 46.09 126 | 44.06 96 | 44.24 147 | 50.99 122 | 48.71 106 | 66.70 123 | 70.33 53 | 77.60 61 | 78.50 57 |
Christian Sormann, Mattia Rossi, Andreas Kuhn and Friedrich Fraundorfer: IB-MVS: An Iterative Algorithm for Deep Multi-View Stereo based on Binary Decisions. BMVC 2021 |
Fast-Effi-MVS+-dtu | | | 56.30 114 | 59.29 115 | 52.82 112 | 58.64 84 | 64.89 97 | 65.56 91 | 32.89 206 | 45.80 135 | 35.04 133 | 45.89 134 | 54.14 95 | 49.41 102 | 67.16 116 | 66.45 92 | 75.37 103 | 70.69 116 |
|
CNLPA | | | 62.78 57 | 66.31 57 | 58.65 56 | 58.47 85 | 68.41 61 | 65.98 87 | 41.22 153 | 78.02 19 | 56.04 32 | 46.65 123 | 59.50 76 | 57.50 39 | 69.67 66 | 65.27 124 | 72.70 137 | 76.67 70 |
|
tpm cat1 | | | 53.30 134 | 53.41 162 | 53.17 109 | 58.16 86 | 59.15 154 | 63.73 104 | 38.27 176 | 50.73 84 | 46.98 66 | 45.57 139 | 44.00 174 | 49.20 104 | 55.90 202 | 54.02 201 | 62.65 195 | 64.50 169 |
|
v1144 | | | 58.88 74 | 60.16 95 | 57.39 69 | 58.03 87 | 67.26 71 | 67.14 60 | 44.46 83 | 45.17 139 | 44.33 95 | 47.81 117 | 49.92 128 | 53.20 71 | 67.77 99 | 66.62 87 | 77.15 67 | 76.58 73 |
|
v7 | | | 59.19 71 | 60.62 80 | 57.53 67 | 57.96 88 | 67.19 73 | 67.09 61 | 44.28 84 | 46.84 117 | 45.45 79 | 48.19 112 | 51.06 119 | 53.62 61 | 67.84 94 | 66.59 88 | 76.79 70 | 76.60 72 |
|
v10 | | | 59.17 72 | 60.60 81 | 57.50 68 | 57.95 89 | 66.73 77 | 67.09 61 | 44.11 86 | 46.85 116 | 45.42 80 | 48.18 114 | 51.07 118 | 53.63 60 | 67.84 94 | 66.59 88 | 76.79 70 | 76.92 68 |
|
v1192 | | | 58.51 86 | 59.66 108 | 57.17 70 | 57.82 90 | 67.72 65 | 66.21 84 | 44.83 79 | 44.15 146 | 43.49 98 | 46.68 122 | 47.94 132 | 53.55 63 | 67.39 113 | 66.51 90 | 77.13 68 | 77.20 66 |
|
DWT-MVSNet_training | | | 53.80 129 | 54.31 154 | 53.21 107 | 57.65 91 | 59.04 155 | 60.65 114 | 40.11 164 | 46.35 121 | 42.77 101 | 49.07 91 | 41.07 189 | 51.06 99 | 58.62 184 | 58.96 179 | 67.00 183 | 67.06 141 |
|
v144192 | | | 58.23 99 | 59.40 114 | 56.87 84 | 57.56 92 | 66.89 75 | 65.70 89 | 45.01 78 | 44.06 147 | 42.88 100 | 46.61 124 | 48.09 131 | 53.49 66 | 66.94 119 | 65.90 100 | 76.61 81 | 77.29 64 |
|
v1921920 | | | 57.89 103 | 59.02 117 | 56.58 91 | 57.55 93 | 66.66 80 | 64.72 98 | 44.70 81 | 43.55 150 | 42.73 102 | 46.17 132 | 46.93 146 | 53.51 64 | 66.78 122 | 65.75 104 | 76.29 87 | 77.28 65 |
|
v13 | | | 58.44 91 | 59.72 107 | 56.94 74 | 57.55 93 | 63.51 105 | 66.86 64 | 42.81 128 | 45.90 131 | 44.98 86 | 48.17 115 | 51.87 113 | 52.68 80 | 68.20 82 | 65.78 102 | 76.78 72 | 74.63 96 |
|
v12 | | | 58.44 91 | 59.74 106 | 56.92 78 | 57.54 95 | 63.50 106 | 66.84 67 | 42.77 129 | 45.96 129 | 44.95 87 | 48.31 108 | 51.94 112 | 52.67 81 | 68.14 85 | 65.75 104 | 76.75 74 | 74.55 98 |
|
v11 | | | 58.19 100 | 59.47 112 | 56.70 89 | 57.54 95 | 63.42 110 | 66.28 83 | 42.49 135 | 45.62 137 | 44.59 93 | 48.16 116 | 50.78 123 | 52.84 72 | 67.80 98 | 65.76 103 | 76.49 84 | 74.76 89 |
|
Vis-MVSNet (Re-imp) | | | 50.37 159 | 57.73 128 | 41.80 191 | 57.53 97 | 54.35 180 | 45.70 197 | 45.24 75 | 49.80 86 | 13.43 211 | 58.23 59 | 56.42 87 | 20.11 211 | 62.96 156 | 63.36 148 | 68.76 172 | 58.96 192 |
|
CostFormer | | | 56.57 113 | 59.13 116 | 53.60 103 | 57.52 98 | 61.12 131 | 66.94 63 | 35.95 188 | 53.44 71 | 44.68 89 | 55.87 67 | 54.44 94 | 48.21 109 | 60.37 174 | 58.33 183 | 68.27 175 | 70.33 119 |
|
V9 | | | 58.45 90 | 59.75 103 | 56.92 78 | 57.51 99 | 63.49 107 | 66.86 64 | 42.73 130 | 46.07 128 | 45.05 84 | 48.45 107 | 51.99 111 | 52.66 82 | 68.04 92 | 65.75 104 | 76.72 75 | 74.50 99 |
|
thres400 | | | 52.38 142 | 55.51 138 | 48.74 143 | 57.49 100 | 60.10 141 | 55.45 145 | 43.54 108 | 42.90 159 | 26.72 173 | 43.34 157 | 45.03 165 | 36.61 167 | 66.20 135 | 64.53 135 | 72.66 138 | 66.43 146 |
|
V14 | | | 58.44 91 | 59.75 103 | 56.90 81 | 57.48 101 | 63.46 108 | 66.85 66 | 42.68 131 | 46.16 125 | 45.03 85 | 48.57 105 | 52.04 110 | 52.65 83 | 67.93 93 | 65.72 107 | 76.69 76 | 74.40 101 |
|
v15 | | | 58.43 94 | 59.75 103 | 56.88 83 | 57.45 102 | 63.44 109 | 66.84 67 | 42.65 132 | 46.24 124 | 45.07 83 | 48.68 104 | 52.07 109 | 52.63 84 | 67.84 94 | 65.70 108 | 76.65 77 | 74.31 104 |
|
thres600view7 | | | 51.91 149 | 55.14 145 | 48.14 150 | 57.43 103 | 60.18 137 | 54.60 155 | 43.73 101 | 42.61 167 | 25.20 178 | 43.10 163 | 44.47 171 | 35.19 171 | 66.36 128 | 63.28 151 | 72.66 138 | 66.01 153 |
|
view600 | | | 51.96 147 | 55.13 146 | 48.27 149 | 57.41 104 | 60.05 142 | 54.74 154 | 43.64 104 | 42.57 168 | 25.88 176 | 43.11 162 | 44.48 170 | 35.34 170 | 66.27 131 | 63.61 145 | 72.61 141 | 65.80 155 |
|
thres200 | | | 52.39 141 | 55.37 143 | 48.90 141 | 57.39 105 | 60.18 137 | 55.60 143 | 43.73 101 | 42.93 158 | 27.41 170 | 43.35 156 | 45.09 160 | 36.61 167 | 66.36 128 | 63.92 143 | 72.66 138 | 65.78 156 |
|
v17 | | | 58.69 80 | 60.19 94 | 56.94 74 | 57.38 106 | 63.37 111 | 66.67 77 | 42.47 137 | 48.52 107 | 46.10 74 | 48.90 99 | 53.00 100 | 52.84 72 | 67.58 101 | 65.60 114 | 76.19 93 | 74.38 102 |
|
view800 | | | 51.55 151 | 54.89 148 | 47.66 157 | 57.37 107 | 59.77 146 | 53.62 161 | 43.72 103 | 42.22 170 | 24.94 179 | 42.80 167 | 43.81 176 | 33.94 177 | 66.09 136 | 64.38 137 | 72.39 144 | 65.14 165 |
|
v1141 | | | 58.56 83 | 60.05 100 | 56.81 87 | 57.36 108 | 66.18 84 | 66.80 69 | 43.11 120 | 45.87 133 | 44.60 91 | 48.71 102 | 51.83 115 | 52.38 88 | 67.46 108 | 65.64 112 | 76.63 78 | 74.66 93 |
|
divwei89l23v2f112 | | | 58.56 83 | 60.05 100 | 56.81 87 | 57.36 108 | 66.18 84 | 66.80 69 | 43.11 120 | 45.89 132 | 44.60 91 | 48.71 102 | 51.84 114 | 52.38 88 | 67.45 110 | 65.65 109 | 76.63 78 | 74.66 93 |
|
v1 | | | 58.56 83 | 60.06 99 | 56.83 86 | 57.36 108 | 66.19 83 | 66.80 69 | 43.10 122 | 45.87 133 | 44.68 89 | 48.73 101 | 51.83 115 | 52.38 88 | 67.45 110 | 65.65 109 | 76.63 78 | 74.66 93 |
|
v16 | | | 58.71 79 | 60.20 91 | 56.97 72 | 57.35 111 | 63.36 112 | 66.67 77 | 42.49 135 | 48.69 103 | 46.36 70 | 48.87 100 | 52.92 105 | 52.82 74 | 67.57 102 | 65.58 118 | 76.15 95 | 74.38 102 |
|
v8 | | | 58.88 74 | 60.57 82 | 56.92 78 | 57.35 111 | 65.69 91 | 66.69 76 | 42.64 133 | 47.89 110 | 45.77 76 | 49.04 92 | 52.98 101 | 52.77 78 | 67.51 107 | 65.57 119 | 76.26 89 | 75.30 86 |
|
tfpn | | | 50.58 156 | 53.65 160 | 47.00 161 | 57.34 113 | 59.31 150 | 52.41 166 | 43.76 98 | 41.81 174 | 23.86 185 | 42.49 170 | 37.80 204 | 32.63 182 | 65.68 143 | 64.02 141 | 71.99 150 | 64.41 170 |
|
v6 | | | 58.89 73 | 60.54 83 | 56.96 73 | 57.34 113 | 66.13 86 | 66.71 72 | 42.84 125 | 47.85 111 | 45.80 75 | 49.04 92 | 52.95 102 | 52.79 75 | 67.53 104 | 65.59 115 | 76.26 89 | 74.73 90 |
|
v1neww | | | 58.88 74 | 60.54 83 | 56.94 74 | 57.33 115 | 66.13 86 | 66.70 74 | 42.84 125 | 47.84 112 | 45.74 77 | 49.02 94 | 52.93 103 | 52.78 76 | 67.53 104 | 65.59 115 | 76.26 89 | 74.73 90 |
|
v7new | | | 58.88 74 | 60.54 83 | 56.94 74 | 57.33 115 | 66.13 86 | 66.70 74 | 42.84 125 | 47.84 112 | 45.74 77 | 49.02 94 | 52.93 103 | 52.78 76 | 67.53 104 | 65.59 115 | 76.26 89 | 74.73 90 |
|
tfpn111 | | | 52.44 139 | 55.38 141 | 49.01 137 | 57.31 117 | 60.24 134 | 55.42 146 | 43.77 95 | 42.85 160 | 27.51 166 | 42.03 175 | 45.06 161 | 37.32 158 | 66.38 125 | 64.54 131 | 72.71 134 | 66.54 143 |
|
conf200view11 | | | 52.51 138 | 55.51 138 | 49.01 137 | 57.31 117 | 60.24 134 | 55.42 146 | 43.77 95 | 42.85 160 | 27.51 166 | 43.00 164 | 45.06 161 | 37.32 158 | 66.38 125 | 64.54 131 | 72.71 134 | 66.54 143 |
|
thres100view900 | | | 52.04 144 | 54.81 150 | 48.80 142 | 57.31 117 | 59.33 149 | 55.30 151 | 42.92 124 | 42.85 160 | 27.81 164 | 43.00 164 | 45.06 161 | 36.99 164 | 64.74 149 | 63.51 146 | 72.47 142 | 65.21 163 |
|
tfpn200view9 | | | 52.53 137 | 55.51 138 | 49.06 135 | 57.31 117 | 60.24 134 | 55.42 146 | 43.77 95 | 42.85 160 | 27.81 164 | 43.00 164 | 45.06 161 | 37.32 158 | 66.38 125 | 64.54 131 | 72.71 134 | 66.54 143 |
|
conf0.01 | | | 52.02 145 | 54.62 151 | 49.00 139 | 57.30 121 | 60.17 139 | 55.42 146 | 43.76 98 | 42.85 160 | 27.49 168 | 43.12 161 | 39.71 197 | 37.32 158 | 66.26 133 | 64.54 131 | 72.72 131 | 65.66 158 |
|
v1240 | | | 57.55 104 | 58.63 120 | 56.29 93 | 57.30 121 | 66.48 81 | 63.77 103 | 44.56 82 | 42.77 166 | 42.48 104 | 45.64 138 | 46.28 151 | 53.46 67 | 66.32 130 | 65.80 101 | 76.16 94 | 77.13 67 |
|
conf0.002 | | | 51.76 150 | 54.13 156 | 49.00 139 | 57.28 123 | 60.15 140 | 55.42 146 | 43.75 100 | 42.85 160 | 27.49 168 | 43.13 160 | 37.12 209 | 37.32 158 | 66.23 134 | 64.17 138 | 72.72 131 | 65.24 162 |
|
v18 | | | 58.68 82 | 60.20 91 | 56.90 81 | 57.26 124 | 63.28 113 | 66.58 79 | 42.42 138 | 48.86 97 | 46.37 69 | 49.01 96 | 53.05 99 | 52.74 79 | 67.40 112 | 65.52 120 | 76.02 100 | 74.28 105 |
|
CHOSEN 1792x2688 | | | 55.85 116 | 58.01 125 | 53.33 105 | 57.26 124 | 62.82 117 | 63.29 107 | 41.55 149 | 46.65 119 | 38.34 119 | 34.55 198 | 53.50 96 | 52.43 87 | 67.10 117 | 67.56 75 | 67.13 180 | 73.92 108 |
|
PVSNet_BlendedMVS | | | 61.63 61 | 64.82 65 | 57.91 64 | 57.21 126 | 67.55 68 | 63.47 105 | 46.08 67 | 54.72 66 | 52.46 53 | 58.59 56 | 60.73 70 | 51.82 96 | 70.46 60 | 65.20 126 | 76.44 85 | 76.50 76 |
|
PVSNet_Blended | | | 61.63 61 | 64.82 65 | 57.91 64 | 57.21 126 | 67.55 68 | 63.47 105 | 46.08 67 | 54.72 66 | 52.46 53 | 58.59 56 | 60.73 70 | 51.82 96 | 70.46 60 | 65.20 126 | 76.44 85 | 76.50 76 |
|
v2v482 | | | 58.69 80 | 60.12 98 | 57.03 71 | 57.16 128 | 66.05 89 | 67.17 59 | 43.52 109 | 46.33 122 | 45.19 82 | 49.46 89 | 51.02 120 | 52.51 86 | 67.30 114 | 66.03 97 | 76.61 81 | 74.62 97 |
|
conf0.05thres1000 | | | 50.64 155 | 53.84 157 | 46.92 162 | 57.02 129 | 59.29 151 | 52.29 167 | 43.80 94 | 39.84 189 | 23.81 186 | 39.26 188 | 43.14 179 | 32.52 183 | 65.74 140 | 64.04 139 | 72.05 149 | 65.53 159 |
|
tfpnnormal | | | 50.16 161 | 52.19 173 | 47.78 156 | 56.86 130 | 58.37 162 | 54.15 156 | 44.01 92 | 38.35 201 | 25.94 175 | 36.10 194 | 37.89 203 | 34.50 174 | 65.93 137 | 63.42 147 | 71.26 156 | 65.28 161 |
|
HyFIR lowres test | | | 56.87 110 | 58.60 121 | 54.84 98 | 56.62 131 | 69.27 57 | 64.77 97 | 42.21 141 | 45.66 136 | 37.50 124 | 33.08 200 | 57.47 84 | 53.33 68 | 65.46 145 | 67.94 70 | 74.60 106 | 71.35 112 |
|
v7n | | | 55.67 117 | 57.46 130 | 53.59 104 | 56.06 132 | 65.29 93 | 61.06 113 | 43.26 117 | 40.17 186 | 37.99 121 | 40.79 182 | 45.27 158 | 47.09 115 | 67.67 100 | 66.21 95 | 76.08 97 | 76.82 69 |
|
dps | | | 50.42 158 | 51.20 184 | 49.51 129 | 55.88 133 | 56.07 171 | 53.73 158 | 38.89 169 | 43.66 148 | 40.36 113 | 45.66 137 | 37.63 206 | 45.23 124 | 59.05 177 | 56.18 186 | 62.94 194 | 60.16 187 |
|
CANet_DTU | | | 58.88 74 | 64.68 67 | 52.12 117 | 55.77 134 | 66.75 76 | 63.92 102 | 37.04 182 | 53.32 73 | 37.45 125 | 59.81 53 | 61.81 67 | 44.43 127 | 68.25 79 | 67.47 76 | 74.12 112 | 75.33 85 |
|
WR-MVS | | | 48.78 171 | 55.06 147 | 41.45 193 | 55.50 135 | 60.40 133 | 43.77 206 | 49.99 52 | 41.92 172 | 8.10 226 | 45.24 143 | 45.56 154 | 17.47 213 | 61.57 168 | 64.60 130 | 73.85 114 | 66.14 152 |
|
UniMVSNet (Re) | | | 55.15 124 | 60.39 87 | 49.03 136 | 55.31 136 | 64.59 100 | 55.77 142 | 50.63 47 | 48.66 104 | 20.95 191 | 51.47 83 | 50.40 125 | 34.41 175 | 67.81 97 | 67.89 71 | 77.11 69 | 71.88 109 |
|
test-LLR | | | 49.28 165 | 50.29 188 | 48.10 151 | 55.26 137 | 47.16 204 | 49.52 173 | 43.48 112 | 39.22 191 | 31.98 142 | 43.65 153 | 47.93 133 | 41.29 141 | 56.80 192 | 55.36 192 | 67.08 181 | 61.94 179 |
|
test0.0.03 1 | | | 43.15 200 | 46.95 201 | 38.72 202 | 55.26 137 | 50.56 193 | 42.48 209 | 43.48 112 | 38.16 203 | 15.11 207 | 35.07 197 | 44.69 168 | 16.47 216 | 55.95 201 | 54.34 200 | 59.54 201 | 49.87 216 |
|
GA-MVS | | | 55.67 117 | 58.33 122 | 52.58 114 | 55.23 139 | 63.09 114 | 61.08 112 | 40.15 163 | 42.95 157 | 37.02 127 | 52.61 78 | 47.68 135 | 47.51 113 | 65.92 138 | 65.35 121 | 74.49 108 | 70.68 117 |
|
thresconf0.02 | | | 48.17 176 | 51.22 183 | 44.60 173 | 55.14 140 | 55.73 173 | 48.95 177 | 41.35 152 | 43.43 154 | 21.23 189 | 42.03 175 | 37.25 208 | 31.19 185 | 62.33 162 | 60.61 171 | 69.76 165 | 57.17 197 |
|
diffmvs | | | 59.53 67 | 64.04 70 | 54.26 100 | 55.09 141 | 59.86 144 | 64.80 96 | 39.55 167 | 58.39 61 | 46.21 73 | 60.48 52 | 67.82 55 | 49.27 103 | 63.53 153 | 63.32 149 | 70.64 159 | 74.89 88 |
|
tfpnview11 | | | 47.58 182 | 51.57 176 | 42.92 184 | 54.94 142 | 55.30 175 | 46.21 191 | 41.58 147 | 42.10 171 | 18.54 198 | 42.25 172 | 41.54 185 | 27.12 196 | 62.29 163 | 61.12 164 | 69.15 167 | 56.40 201 |
|
tfpn_n400 | | | 47.56 183 | 51.56 177 | 42.90 185 | 54.91 143 | 55.28 176 | 46.21 191 | 41.59 145 | 41.51 177 | 18.54 198 | 42.25 172 | 41.54 185 | 27.12 196 | 62.41 160 | 61.02 166 | 69.05 168 | 56.90 199 |
|
tfpnconf | | | 47.56 183 | 51.56 177 | 42.90 185 | 54.91 143 | 55.28 176 | 46.21 191 | 41.59 145 | 41.51 177 | 18.54 198 | 42.25 172 | 41.54 185 | 27.12 196 | 62.41 160 | 61.02 166 | 69.05 168 | 56.90 199 |
|
Anonymous20231211 | | | 42.68 201 | 41.57 213 | 43.96 176 | 54.71 145 | 52.32 188 | 41.42 212 | 45.09 77 | 24.45 226 | 31.78 146 | 14.58 230 | 23.43 229 | 23.08 206 | 56.20 198 | 58.74 181 | 67.68 178 | 61.31 182 |
|
DTE-MVSNet | | | 48.03 179 | 53.28 164 | 41.91 190 | 54.64 146 | 57.50 167 | 44.63 204 | 51.66 43 | 41.02 181 | 7.97 227 | 46.26 129 | 40.90 190 | 20.24 210 | 60.45 173 | 62.89 155 | 72.33 146 | 63.97 171 |
|
pmmvs4 | | | 54.66 127 | 56.07 136 | 53.00 110 | 54.63 147 | 57.08 169 | 60.43 118 | 44.10 87 | 51.69 81 | 40.55 112 | 46.55 127 | 44.79 166 | 45.95 122 | 62.54 158 | 63.66 144 | 72.36 145 | 66.20 150 |
|
DU-MVS | | | 55.41 120 | 59.59 109 | 50.54 123 | 54.60 148 | 62.97 115 | 57.44 128 | 51.80 40 | 48.62 105 | 24.31 183 | 51.99 81 | 47.00 145 | 39.04 149 | 68.11 86 | 67.75 73 | 76.03 99 | 70.72 114 |
|
Baseline_NR-MVSNet | | | 53.50 132 | 57.89 126 | 48.37 147 | 54.60 148 | 59.25 153 | 56.10 138 | 51.84 39 | 49.32 92 | 17.92 203 | 45.38 140 | 47.68 135 | 36.93 165 | 68.11 86 | 65.95 98 | 72.84 129 | 69.57 125 |
|
v148 | | | 55.58 119 | 57.61 129 | 53.20 108 | 54.59 150 | 61.86 120 | 61.18 111 | 38.70 173 | 44.30 145 | 42.25 105 | 47.53 118 | 50.24 127 | 48.73 105 | 65.15 147 | 62.61 159 | 73.79 115 | 71.61 111 |
|
tfpn1000 | | | 46.75 189 | 51.24 182 | 41.51 192 | 54.39 151 | 55.60 174 | 43.85 205 | 40.90 155 | 41.82 173 | 16.71 205 | 41.26 179 | 41.58 184 | 23.96 203 | 60.76 171 | 60.27 174 | 69.26 166 | 57.42 196 |
|
tfpn_ndepth | | | 48.34 174 | 52.27 171 | 43.76 177 | 54.35 152 | 56.46 170 | 47.24 187 | 40.92 154 | 43.45 152 | 21.04 190 | 41.16 180 | 43.22 178 | 28.90 193 | 61.57 168 | 60.65 170 | 70.12 163 | 59.34 190 |
|
PEN-MVS | | | 49.21 167 | 54.32 153 | 43.24 183 | 54.33 153 | 59.26 152 | 47.04 188 | 51.37 44 | 41.67 175 | 9.97 221 | 46.22 130 | 41.80 183 | 22.97 208 | 60.52 172 | 64.03 140 | 73.73 116 | 66.75 142 |
|
pm-mvs1 | | | 51.02 154 | 55.55 137 | 45.73 166 | 54.16 154 | 58.52 159 | 50.92 170 | 42.56 134 | 40.32 185 | 25.67 177 | 43.66 152 | 50.34 126 | 30.06 188 | 65.85 139 | 63.97 142 | 70.99 158 | 66.21 149 |
|
EPNet_dtu | | | 52.05 143 | 58.26 123 | 44.81 171 | 54.10 155 | 50.09 196 | 52.01 168 | 40.82 158 | 53.03 76 | 27.41 170 | 54.90 69 | 57.96 83 | 26.72 199 | 62.97 155 | 62.70 158 | 67.78 177 | 66.19 151 |
Wanjuan Su, Wenbing Tao: Efficient Edge-Preserving Multi-View Stereo Network for Depth Estimation. AAAI 2023 |
tpm | | | 48.82 170 | 51.27 181 | 45.96 165 | 54.10 155 | 47.35 203 | 56.05 139 | 30.23 211 | 46.70 118 | 43.21 99 | 52.54 79 | 47.55 138 | 37.28 163 | 54.11 207 | 50.50 212 | 54.90 213 | 60.12 188 |
|
CDS-MVSNet | | | 52.42 140 | 57.06 133 | 47.02 160 | 53.92 157 | 58.30 163 | 55.50 144 | 46.47 65 | 42.52 169 | 29.38 158 | 49.50 88 | 52.85 106 | 28.49 194 | 66.70 123 | 66.89 82 | 68.34 173 | 62.63 178 |
Khang Truong Giang, Soohwan Song, Sungho Jo: Curvature-guided dynamic scale networks for Multi-view Stereo. ICLR 2022 |
test20.03 | | | 40.38 210 | 44.20 208 | 35.92 209 | 53.73 158 | 49.05 197 | 38.54 216 | 43.49 111 | 32.55 213 | 9.54 222 | 27.88 214 | 39.12 199 | 12.24 227 | 56.28 197 | 54.69 197 | 57.96 206 | 49.83 217 |
|
Vis-MVSNet | | | 58.48 88 | 65.70 61 | 50.06 126 | 53.40 159 | 67.20 72 | 60.24 119 | 43.32 115 | 48.83 98 | 30.23 153 | 62.38 46 | 61.61 69 | 40.35 144 | 71.03 58 | 69.77 58 | 72.82 130 | 79.11 54 |
Jingyang Zhang, Yao Yao, Shiwei Li, Zixin Luo, Tian Fang: Visibility-aware Multiview Stereo Network. BMVC 2020 |
PLC | | 52.09 14 | 59.21 70 | 62.47 73 | 55.41 97 | 53.24 160 | 64.84 98 | 64.47 100 | 40.41 161 | 65.92 49 | 44.53 94 | 46.19 131 | 55.69 92 | 55.33 54 | 68.24 81 | 65.30 123 | 74.50 107 | 71.09 113 |
Jie Liao, Yanping Fu, Qingan Yan, Chunxia xiao: Pyramid Multi-View Stereo with Local Consistency. Pacific Graphics 2019 |
OMC-MVS | | | 65.16 51 | 71.35 41 | 57.94 62 | 52.95 161 | 68.82 58 | 69.00 52 | 38.28 175 | 79.89 12 | 55.20 37 | 62.76 43 | 68.31 51 | 56.14 50 | 71.30 55 | 68.70 65 | 76.06 98 | 79.67 52 |
|
tpmrst | | | 48.08 177 | 49.88 192 | 45.98 164 | 52.71 162 | 48.11 201 | 53.62 161 | 33.70 199 | 48.70 102 | 39.74 115 | 48.96 97 | 46.23 152 | 40.29 145 | 50.14 216 | 49.28 214 | 55.80 210 | 57.71 195 |
|
GBi-Net | | | 55.20 122 | 60.25 89 | 49.31 130 | 52.42 163 | 61.44 125 | 57.03 131 | 44.04 89 | 49.18 93 | 30.47 149 | 48.28 109 | 58.19 80 | 38.22 152 | 68.05 89 | 66.96 79 | 73.69 117 | 69.65 122 |
|
test1 | | | 55.20 122 | 60.25 89 | 49.31 130 | 52.42 163 | 61.44 125 | 57.03 131 | 44.04 89 | 49.18 93 | 30.47 149 | 48.28 109 | 58.19 80 | 38.22 152 | 68.05 89 | 66.96 79 | 73.69 117 | 69.65 122 |
|
FMVSNet2 | | | 55.04 125 | 59.95 102 | 49.31 130 | 52.42 163 | 61.44 125 | 57.03 131 | 44.08 88 | 49.55 88 | 30.40 152 | 46.89 121 | 58.84 78 | 38.22 152 | 67.07 118 | 66.21 95 | 73.69 117 | 69.65 122 |
|
FMVSNet3 | | | 54.78 126 | 59.58 110 | 49.17 133 | 52.37 166 | 61.31 129 | 56.72 135 | 44.04 89 | 49.18 93 | 30.47 149 | 48.28 109 | 58.19 80 | 38.09 155 | 65.48 144 | 65.20 126 | 73.31 123 | 69.45 130 |
|
testgi | | | 38.71 212 | 43.64 209 | 32.95 214 | 52.30 167 | 48.63 200 | 35.59 222 | 35.05 191 | 31.58 217 | 9.03 225 | 30.29 205 | 40.75 192 | 11.19 232 | 55.30 203 | 53.47 206 | 54.53 215 | 45.48 220 |
|
Anonymous20231206 | | | 42.28 202 | 45.89 203 | 38.07 204 | 51.96 168 | 48.98 198 | 43.66 207 | 38.81 172 | 38.74 197 | 14.32 210 | 26.74 215 | 40.90 190 | 20.94 209 | 56.64 195 | 54.67 198 | 58.71 202 | 54.59 203 |
|
pmmvs6 | | | 48.35 173 | 51.64 175 | 44.51 174 | 51.92 169 | 57.94 165 | 49.44 175 | 42.17 142 | 34.45 209 | 24.62 182 | 28.87 213 | 46.90 147 | 29.07 192 | 64.60 150 | 63.08 152 | 69.83 164 | 65.68 157 |
|
v748 | | | 52.93 135 | 55.29 144 | 50.19 125 | 51.90 170 | 61.31 129 | 56.54 136 | 40.05 165 | 39.12 193 | 34.82 136 | 39.93 185 | 43.83 175 | 43.66 129 | 64.26 151 | 63.32 149 | 74.15 111 | 75.28 87 |
|
PatchmatchNet | | | 49.92 163 | 51.29 180 | 48.32 148 | 51.83 171 | 51.86 190 | 53.38 164 | 37.63 180 | 47.90 109 | 40.83 111 | 48.54 106 | 45.30 157 | 45.19 125 | 56.86 191 | 53.99 203 | 61.08 199 | 54.57 204 |
Fangjinhua Wang, Silvano Galliani, Christoph Vogel, Pablo Speciale, Marc Pollefeys: PatchmatchNet: Learned Multi-View Patchmatch Stereo. |
WR-MVS_H | | | 47.65 180 | 53.67 159 | 40.63 196 | 51.45 172 | 59.74 147 | 44.71 203 | 49.37 55 | 40.69 183 | 7.61 228 | 46.04 133 | 44.34 173 | 17.32 214 | 57.79 188 | 61.18 163 | 73.30 124 | 65.86 154 |
|
LTVRE_ROB | | 44.17 16 | 47.06 188 | 50.15 191 | 43.44 180 | 51.39 173 | 58.42 160 | 42.90 208 | 43.51 110 | 22.27 231 | 14.85 209 | 41.94 178 | 34.57 211 | 45.43 123 | 62.28 164 | 62.77 157 | 62.56 196 | 68.83 133 |
Andreas Kuhn, Heiko Hirschmüller, Daniel Scharstein, Helmut Mayer: A TV Prior for High-Quality Scalable Multi-View Stereo Reconstruction. International Journal of Computer Vision 2016 |
CP-MVSNet | | | 48.37 172 | 53.53 161 | 42.34 188 | 51.35 174 | 58.01 164 | 46.56 189 | 50.54 48 | 41.62 176 | 10.61 217 | 46.53 128 | 40.68 193 | 23.18 205 | 58.71 182 | 61.83 161 | 71.81 151 | 67.36 139 |
|
PS-CasMVS | | | 48.18 175 | 53.25 165 | 42.27 189 | 51.26 175 | 57.94 165 | 46.51 190 | 50.52 49 | 41.30 179 | 10.56 219 | 45.35 142 | 40.34 195 | 23.04 207 | 58.66 183 | 61.79 162 | 71.74 153 | 67.38 138 |
|
our_test_3 | | | | | | 51.15 176 | 57.31 168 | 55.12 152 | | | | | | | | | | |
|
FMVSNet1 | | | 54.08 128 | 58.68 119 | 48.71 144 | 50.90 177 | 61.35 128 | 56.73 134 | 43.94 93 | 45.91 130 | 29.32 159 | 42.72 168 | 56.26 90 | 37.70 156 | 68.05 89 | 66.96 79 | 73.69 117 | 69.50 126 |
|
pmmvs-eth3d | | | 51.33 152 | 52.25 172 | 50.26 124 | 50.82 178 | 54.65 179 | 56.03 140 | 43.45 114 | 43.51 151 | 37.20 126 | 39.20 189 | 39.04 200 | 42.28 136 | 61.85 167 | 62.78 156 | 71.78 152 | 64.72 167 |
|
MVSTER | | | 57.19 105 | 61.11 78 | 52.62 113 | 50.82 178 | 58.79 157 | 61.55 109 | 37.86 178 | 48.81 99 | 41.31 109 | 57.43 62 | 52.10 108 | 48.60 107 | 68.19 84 | 66.75 83 | 75.56 102 | 75.68 83 |
|
ambc | | | | 45.54 206 | | 50.66 180 | 52.63 187 | 40.99 213 | | 38.36 200 | 24.67 181 | 22.62 222 | 13.94 235 | 29.14 191 | 65.71 142 | 58.06 184 | 58.60 204 | 67.43 137 |
|
MDTV_nov1_ep13 | | | 50.32 160 | 52.43 170 | 47.86 155 | 49.87 181 | 54.70 178 | 58.10 125 | 34.29 194 | 45.59 138 | 37.71 122 | 47.44 119 | 47.42 139 | 41.86 138 | 58.07 187 | 55.21 194 | 65.34 188 | 58.56 193 |
|
IterMVS | | | 53.45 133 | 57.12 132 | 49.17 133 | 49.23 182 | 60.93 132 | 59.05 122 | 34.63 192 | 44.53 141 | 33.22 137 | 51.09 85 | 51.01 121 | 48.38 108 | 62.43 159 | 60.79 169 | 70.54 161 | 69.05 132 |
Fangjinhua Wang, Silvano Galliani, Christoph Vogel, Marc Pollefeys: IterMVS: Iterative Probability Estimation for Efficient Multi-View Stereo. |
COLMAP_ROB | | 46.52 15 | 51.99 146 | 54.86 149 | 48.63 145 | 49.13 183 | 61.73 122 | 60.53 117 | 36.57 185 | 53.14 74 | 32.95 140 | 37.10 192 | 38.68 201 | 40.49 143 | 65.72 141 | 63.08 152 | 72.11 148 | 64.60 168 |
Johannes L. Schönberger, Enliang Zheng, Marc Pollefeys, Jan-Michael Frahm: Pixelwise View Selection for Unstructured Multi-View Stereo. ECCV 2016 |
CR-MVSNet | | | 50.47 157 | 52.61 167 | 47.98 153 | 49.03 184 | 52.94 184 | 48.27 179 | 38.86 170 | 44.41 142 | 39.59 116 | 44.34 146 | 44.65 169 | 46.63 119 | 58.97 179 | 60.31 172 | 65.48 186 | 62.66 176 |
|
V42 | | | 56.97 108 | 60.14 96 | 53.28 106 | 48.16 185 | 62.78 118 | 66.30 82 | 37.93 177 | 47.44 114 | 42.68 103 | 48.19 112 | 52.59 107 | 51.90 94 | 67.46 108 | 65.94 99 | 72.72 131 | 76.55 75 |
|
MDTV_nov1_ep13_2view | | | 47.62 181 | 49.72 193 | 45.18 169 | 48.05 186 | 53.70 182 | 54.90 153 | 33.80 198 | 39.90 188 | 29.79 156 | 38.85 190 | 41.89 182 | 39.17 148 | 58.99 178 | 55.55 191 | 65.34 188 | 59.17 191 |
|
EPMVS | | | 44.66 196 | 47.86 199 | 40.92 195 | 47.97 187 | 44.70 214 | 47.58 184 | 33.27 202 | 48.11 108 | 29.58 157 | 49.65 87 | 44.38 172 | 34.65 172 | 51.71 211 | 47.90 218 | 52.49 218 | 48.57 218 |
|
RPMNet | | | 46.41 190 | 48.72 195 | 43.72 178 | 47.77 188 | 52.94 184 | 46.02 196 | 33.92 196 | 44.41 142 | 31.82 145 | 36.89 193 | 37.42 207 | 37.41 157 | 53.88 208 | 54.02 201 | 65.37 187 | 61.47 181 |
|
testpf | | | 34.85 217 | 36.16 222 | 33.31 213 | 47.49 189 | 35.56 228 | 36.85 219 | 32.31 209 | 23.08 228 | 15.63 206 | 29.39 210 | 29.48 218 | 19.62 212 | 41.38 229 | 41.07 228 | 47.95 225 | 53.18 205 |
|
TAPA-MVS | | 54.74 10 | 60.85 63 | 66.61 55 | 54.12 102 | 47.38 190 | 65.33 92 | 65.35 93 | 36.51 186 | 75.16 26 | 48.82 63 | 54.70 71 | 63.51 61 | 53.31 69 | 68.36 77 | 64.97 129 | 73.37 122 | 74.27 106 |
Andrea Romanoni, Matteo Matteucci: TAPA-MVS: Textureless-Aware PAtchMatch Multi-View Stereo. ICCV 2019 |
SixPastTwentyTwo | | | 47.55 185 | 50.25 190 | 44.41 175 | 47.30 191 | 54.31 181 | 47.81 182 | 40.36 162 | 33.76 210 | 19.93 195 | 43.75 151 | 32.77 215 | 42.07 137 | 59.82 175 | 60.94 168 | 68.98 170 | 66.37 148 |
|
TAMVS | | | 44.02 198 | 49.18 194 | 37.99 205 | 47.03 192 | 45.97 211 | 45.04 200 | 28.47 216 | 39.11 194 | 20.23 194 | 43.22 159 | 48.52 129 | 28.49 194 | 58.15 186 | 57.95 185 | 58.71 202 | 51.36 209 |
|
UGNet | | | 57.03 106 | 65.25 63 | 47.44 158 | 46.54 193 | 66.73 77 | 56.30 137 | 43.28 116 | 50.06 85 | 32.99 139 | 62.57 45 | 63.26 62 | 33.31 179 | 68.25 79 | 67.58 74 | 72.20 147 | 78.29 59 |
Wanjuan Su, Qingshan Xu, Wenbing Tao: Uncertainty-guided Multi-view Stereo Network for Depth Estimation. IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems for Video Technology, 2022 |
TSAR-MVS + COLMAP | | | 62.65 58 | 69.90 49 | 54.19 101 | 46.31 194 | 66.73 77 | 65.49 92 | 41.36 151 | 76.57 21 | 46.31 71 | 76.80 13 | 56.68 86 | 53.27 70 | 69.50 67 | 66.65 86 | 72.40 143 | 76.36 78 |
|
PatchMatch-RL | | | 50.11 162 | 51.56 177 | 48.43 146 | 46.23 195 | 51.94 189 | 50.21 172 | 38.62 174 | 46.62 120 | 37.51 123 | 42.43 171 | 39.38 198 | 52.24 92 | 60.98 170 | 59.56 176 | 65.76 185 | 60.01 189 |
|
CMPMVS | | 37.70 17 | 49.24 166 | 52.71 166 | 45.19 168 | 45.97 196 | 51.23 192 | 47.44 185 | 29.31 213 | 43.04 156 | 44.69 88 | 34.45 199 | 48.35 130 | 43.64 130 | 62.59 157 | 59.82 175 | 60.08 200 | 69.48 127 |
M. Jancosek, T. Pajdla: Multi-View Reconstruction Preserving Weakly-Supported Surfaces. CVPR 2011 |
v52 | | | 53.60 130 | 56.74 134 | 49.93 127 | 45.54 197 | 61.64 123 | 60.65 114 | 36.99 183 | 38.75 195 | 36.32 129 | 39.64 186 | 47.13 142 | 47.05 116 | 66.89 120 | 65.65 109 | 73.04 126 | 77.48 62 |
|
V4 | | | 53.60 130 | 56.73 135 | 49.93 127 | 45.54 197 | 61.64 123 | 60.65 114 | 36.99 183 | 38.74 197 | 36.33 128 | 39.64 186 | 47.12 143 | 47.05 116 | 66.89 120 | 65.64 112 | 73.04 126 | 77.48 62 |
|
pmmvs5 | | | 47.07 187 | 51.02 186 | 42.46 187 | 45.18 199 | 51.47 191 | 48.23 181 | 33.09 205 | 38.17 202 | 28.62 162 | 46.60 125 | 43.48 177 | 30.74 186 | 58.28 185 | 58.63 182 | 68.92 171 | 60.48 185 |
|
USDC | | | 51.11 153 | 53.71 158 | 48.08 152 | 44.76 200 | 55.99 172 | 53.01 165 | 40.90 155 | 52.49 78 | 36.14 130 | 44.67 145 | 33.66 213 | 43.27 134 | 63.23 154 | 61.10 165 | 70.39 162 | 64.82 166 |
|
FC-MVSNet-test | | | 39.65 211 | 48.35 197 | 29.49 218 | 44.43 201 | 39.28 221 | 30.23 228 | 40.44 160 | 43.59 149 | 3.12 238 | 53.00 76 | 42.03 181 | 10.02 234 | 55.09 204 | 54.77 196 | 48.66 223 | 50.71 211 |
|
ADS-MVSNet | | | 40.67 208 | 43.38 210 | 37.50 206 | 44.36 202 | 39.79 220 | 42.09 211 | 32.67 208 | 44.34 144 | 28.87 161 | 40.76 183 | 40.37 194 | 30.22 187 | 48.34 226 | 45.87 224 | 46.81 227 | 44.21 222 |
|
new-patchmatchnet | | | 33.24 220 | 37.20 218 | 28.62 221 | 44.32 203 | 38.26 225 | 29.68 231 | 36.05 187 | 31.97 215 | 6.33 230 | 26.59 216 | 27.33 220 | 11.12 233 | 50.08 217 | 41.05 229 | 44.23 228 | 45.15 221 |
|
1111 | | | 31.35 222 | 33.52 226 | 28.83 219 | 44.28 204 | 32.44 229 | 31.71 226 | 33.25 203 | 27.87 220 | 10.92 215 | 22.18 223 | 24.05 225 | 15.89 218 | 49.03 224 | 44.09 225 | 36.94 232 | 34.96 228 |
|
.test1245 | | | 22.44 230 | 22.23 231 | 22.67 228 | 44.28 204 | 32.44 229 | 31.71 226 | 33.25 203 | 27.87 220 | 10.92 215 | 22.18 223 | 24.05 225 | 15.89 218 | 49.03 224 | 0.01 236 | 0.00 240 | 0.06 238 |
|
MVS-HIRNet | | | 42.24 203 | 41.15 215 | 43.51 179 | 44.06 206 | 40.74 217 | 35.77 221 | 35.35 189 | 35.38 207 | 38.34 119 | 25.63 217 | 38.55 202 | 43.48 132 | 50.77 213 | 47.03 222 | 64.07 190 | 49.98 214 |
|
PatchT | | | 48.08 177 | 51.03 185 | 44.64 172 | 42.96 207 | 50.12 195 | 40.36 214 | 35.09 190 | 43.17 155 | 39.59 116 | 42.00 177 | 39.96 196 | 46.63 119 | 58.97 179 | 60.31 172 | 63.21 193 | 62.66 176 |
|
CVMVSNet | | | 46.38 192 | 52.01 174 | 39.81 198 | 42.40 208 | 50.26 194 | 46.15 194 | 37.68 179 | 40.03 187 | 15.09 208 | 46.56 126 | 47.56 137 | 33.72 178 | 56.50 196 | 55.65 190 | 63.80 192 | 67.53 136 |
|
TinyColmap | | | 47.08 186 | 47.56 200 | 46.52 163 | 42.35 209 | 53.44 183 | 51.77 169 | 40.70 159 | 43.44 153 | 31.92 144 | 29.78 208 | 23.72 228 | 45.04 126 | 61.99 165 | 59.54 177 | 67.35 179 | 61.03 183 |
|
MIMVSNet | | | 43.79 199 | 48.53 196 | 38.27 203 | 41.46 210 | 48.97 199 | 50.81 171 | 32.88 207 | 44.55 140 | 22.07 187 | 32.05 201 | 47.15 141 | 24.76 202 | 58.73 181 | 56.09 188 | 57.63 207 | 52.14 207 |
|
LP | | | 40.79 207 | 41.99 212 | 39.38 199 | 40.98 211 | 46.49 210 | 42.14 210 | 33.66 200 | 35.37 208 | 29.89 155 | 29.30 211 | 27.81 219 | 32.74 180 | 52.55 209 | 52.19 209 | 56.87 208 | 50.23 213 |
|
N_pmnet | | | 32.67 221 | 36.85 219 | 27.79 222 | 40.55 212 | 32.13 231 | 35.80 220 | 26.79 222 | 37.24 205 | 9.10 223 | 32.02 202 | 30.94 216 | 16.30 217 | 47.22 227 | 41.21 227 | 38.21 230 | 37.21 227 |
|
anonymousdsp | | | 52.84 136 | 57.78 127 | 47.06 159 | 40.24 213 | 58.95 156 | 53.70 159 | 33.54 201 | 36.51 206 | 32.69 141 | 43.88 149 | 45.40 155 | 47.97 112 | 67.17 115 | 70.28 54 | 74.22 110 | 82.29 43 |
|
EU-MVSNet | | | 40.63 209 | 45.65 205 | 34.78 212 | 39.11 214 | 46.94 207 | 40.02 215 | 34.03 195 | 33.50 211 | 10.37 220 | 35.57 196 | 37.80 204 | 23.65 204 | 51.90 210 | 50.21 213 | 61.49 198 | 63.62 174 |
|
FPMVS | | | 38.36 213 | 40.41 216 | 35.97 208 | 38.92 215 | 39.85 219 | 45.50 198 | 25.79 225 | 41.13 180 | 18.70 197 | 30.10 206 | 24.56 223 | 31.86 184 | 49.42 221 | 46.80 223 | 55.04 211 | 51.03 210 |
|
testus | | | 31.33 223 | 36.31 221 | 25.52 226 | 37.55 216 | 38.40 222 | 25.87 232 | 23.58 228 | 26.46 223 | 5.97 231 | 24.15 219 | 24.92 222 | 12.44 226 | 49.14 223 | 48.21 217 | 47.73 226 | 42.86 223 |
|
test2356 | | | 33.40 219 | 36.53 220 | 29.76 217 | 37.51 217 | 38.39 223 | 34.68 223 | 27.35 218 | 27.88 219 | 10.61 217 | 25.54 218 | 24.44 224 | 17.15 215 | 49.99 218 | 48.32 216 | 51.24 220 | 41.16 226 |
|
TESTMET0.1,1 | | | 46.09 193 | 50.29 188 | 41.18 194 | 36.91 218 | 47.16 204 | 49.52 173 | 20.32 230 | 39.22 191 | 31.98 142 | 43.65 153 | 47.93 133 | 41.29 141 | 56.80 192 | 55.36 192 | 67.08 181 | 61.94 179 |
|
testmv | | | 30.97 224 | 34.42 224 | 26.95 223 | 36.49 219 | 37.38 226 | 29.80 229 | 27.28 219 | 22.34 229 | 4.72 232 | 20.63 227 | 20.64 231 | 13.22 224 | 49.86 220 | 47.74 219 | 50.20 221 | 42.36 224 |
|
test1235678 | | | 30.97 224 | 34.42 224 | 26.95 223 | 36.49 219 | 37.38 226 | 29.79 230 | 27.28 219 | 22.33 230 | 4.72 232 | 20.62 228 | 20.64 231 | 13.22 224 | 49.87 219 | 47.74 219 | 50.20 221 | 42.36 224 |
|
FMVSNet5 | | | 40.96 205 | 45.81 204 | 35.29 211 | 34.30 221 | 44.55 215 | 47.28 186 | 28.84 215 | 40.76 182 | 21.62 188 | 29.85 207 | 42.44 180 | 24.77 201 | 57.53 189 | 55.00 195 | 54.93 212 | 50.56 212 |
|
PMMVS | | | 49.20 168 | 54.28 155 | 43.28 182 | 34.13 222 | 45.70 212 | 48.98 176 | 26.09 224 | 46.31 123 | 34.92 135 | 55.22 68 | 53.47 97 | 47.48 114 | 59.43 176 | 59.04 178 | 68.05 176 | 60.77 184 |
|
PMVS | | 27.84 18 | 33.81 218 | 35.28 223 | 32.09 215 | 34.13 222 | 24.81 235 | 32.51 225 | 26.48 223 | 26.41 224 | 19.37 196 | 23.76 220 | 24.02 227 | 25.18 200 | 50.78 212 | 47.24 221 | 54.89 214 | 49.95 215 |
Y. Furukawa, J. Ponce: Accurate, dense, and robust multiview stereopsis. PAMI (2010) |
test-mter | | | 45.30 194 | 50.37 187 | 39.38 199 | 33.65 224 | 46.99 206 | 47.59 183 | 18.59 232 | 38.75 195 | 28.00 163 | 43.28 158 | 46.82 148 | 41.50 140 | 57.28 190 | 55.78 189 | 66.93 184 | 63.70 173 |
|
CHOSEN 280x420 | | | 40.80 206 | 45.05 207 | 35.84 210 | 32.95 225 | 29.57 232 | 44.98 201 | 23.71 227 | 37.54 204 | 18.42 201 | 31.36 204 | 47.07 144 | 46.41 121 | 56.71 194 | 54.65 199 | 48.55 224 | 58.47 194 |
|
PM-MVS | | | 44.55 197 | 48.13 198 | 40.37 197 | 32.85 226 | 46.82 208 | 46.11 195 | 29.28 214 | 40.48 184 | 29.99 154 | 39.98 184 | 34.39 212 | 41.80 139 | 56.08 200 | 53.88 205 | 62.19 197 | 65.31 160 |
|
no-one | | | 29.19 226 | 31.89 227 | 26.05 225 | 30.96 227 | 38.33 224 | 21.54 233 | 29.86 212 | 15.84 235 | 3.56 235 | 11.28 234 | 13.03 236 | 14.44 223 | 38.96 230 | 52.83 207 | 55.96 209 | 52.92 206 |
|
TDRefinement | | | 49.31 164 | 52.44 169 | 45.67 167 | 30.44 228 | 59.42 148 | 59.24 121 | 39.78 166 | 48.76 100 | 31.20 148 | 35.73 195 | 29.90 217 | 42.81 135 | 64.24 152 | 62.59 160 | 70.55 160 | 66.43 146 |
|
Gipuma | | | 25.87 227 | 26.91 230 | 24.66 227 | 28.98 229 | 20.17 236 | 20.46 235 | 34.62 193 | 29.55 218 | 9.10 223 | 4.91 238 | 5.31 240 | 15.76 220 | 49.37 222 | 49.10 215 | 39.03 229 | 29.95 231 |
S. Galliani, K. Lasinger, K. Schindler: Massively Parallel Multiview Stereopsis by Surface Normal Diffusion. ICCV 2015 |
MDA-MVSNet-bldmvs | | | 41.36 204 | 43.15 211 | 39.27 201 | 28.74 230 | 52.68 186 | 44.95 202 | 40.84 157 | 32.89 212 | 18.13 202 | 31.61 203 | 22.09 230 | 38.97 151 | 50.45 215 | 56.11 187 | 64.01 191 | 56.23 202 |
|
E-PMN | | | 15.09 232 | 13.19 234 | 17.30 231 | 27.80 231 | 12.62 239 | 7.81 239 | 27.54 217 | 14.62 237 | 3.19 236 | 6.89 235 | 2.52 243 | 15.09 221 | 15.93 234 | 20.22 233 | 22.38 234 | 19.53 234 |
|
MIMVSNet1 | | | 35.51 215 | 41.41 214 | 28.63 220 | 27.53 232 | 43.36 216 | 38.09 217 | 33.82 197 | 32.01 214 | 6.77 229 | 21.63 225 | 35.43 210 | 11.97 229 | 55.05 205 | 53.99 203 | 53.59 217 | 48.36 219 |
|
EMVS | | | 14.49 233 | 12.45 235 | 16.87 233 | 27.02 233 | 12.56 240 | 8.13 238 | 27.19 221 | 15.05 236 | 3.14 237 | 6.69 236 | 2.67 242 | 15.08 222 | 14.60 236 | 18.05 234 | 20.67 235 | 17.56 236 |
|
test12356 | | | 23.91 228 | 28.47 228 | 18.60 229 | 26.80 234 | 28.30 233 | 20.92 234 | 19.76 231 | 19.89 232 | 2.88 240 | 18.48 229 | 16.57 234 | 4.05 235 | 42.34 228 | 41.93 226 | 37.21 231 | 31.75 229 |
|
pmmvs3 | | | 35.10 216 | 38.47 217 | 31.17 216 | 26.37 235 | 40.47 218 | 34.51 224 | 18.09 233 | 24.75 225 | 16.88 204 | 23.05 221 | 26.69 221 | 32.69 181 | 50.73 214 | 51.60 210 | 58.46 205 | 51.98 208 |
|
RPSCF | | | 46.41 190 | 54.42 152 | 37.06 207 | 25.70 236 | 45.14 213 | 45.39 199 | 20.81 229 | 62.79 55 | 35.10 132 | 44.92 144 | 55.60 93 | 43.56 131 | 56.12 199 | 52.45 208 | 51.80 219 | 63.91 172 |
|
new_pmnet | | | 23.19 229 | 28.17 229 | 17.37 230 | 17.03 237 | 24.92 234 | 19.66 236 | 16.16 235 | 27.05 222 | 4.42 234 | 20.77 226 | 19.20 233 | 12.19 228 | 37.71 231 | 36.38 230 | 34.77 233 | 31.17 230 |
|
PMMVS2 | | | 15.84 231 | 19.68 232 | 11.35 234 | 15.74 238 | 16.95 237 | 13.31 237 | 17.64 234 | 16.08 234 | 0.36 242 | 13.12 231 | 11.47 237 | 1.69 237 | 28.82 232 | 27.24 232 | 19.38 236 | 24.09 233 |
|
MVE | | 12.28 19 | 13.53 234 | 15.72 233 | 10.96 235 | 7.39 239 | 15.71 238 | 6.05 240 | 23.73 226 | 10.29 239 | 3.01 239 | 5.77 237 | 3.41 241 | 11.91 230 | 20.11 233 | 29.79 231 | 13.67 237 | 24.98 232 |
Simon Fuhrmann, Fabian Langguth, Michael Goesele: MVE - A Multi-View Reconstruction Environment. EUROGRAPHICS Workshops on Graphics and Cultural Heritage (2014) |
tmp_tt | | | | | 5.40 236 | 3.97 240 | 2.35 242 | 3.26 242 | 0.44 237 | 17.56 233 | 12.09 212 | 11.48 233 | 7.14 238 | 1.98 236 | 15.68 235 | 15.49 235 | 10.69 238 | |
|
GG-mvs-BLEND | | | 36.62 214 | 53.39 163 | 17.06 232 | 0.01 241 | 58.61 158 | 48.63 178 | 0.01 238 | 47.13 115 | 0.02 243 | 43.98 148 | 60.64 72 | 0.03 238 | 54.92 206 | 51.47 211 | 53.64 216 | 56.99 198 |
|
sosnet-low-res | | | 0.00 237 | 0.00 238 | 0.00 237 | 0.00 242 | 0.00 243 | 0.00 245 | 0.00 239 | 0.00 242 | 0.00 244 | 0.00 241 | 0.00 244 | 0.00 241 | 0.00 239 | 0.00 239 | 0.00 240 | 0.00 240 |
|
sosnet | | | 0.00 237 | 0.00 238 | 0.00 237 | 0.00 242 | 0.00 243 | 0.00 245 | 0.00 239 | 0.00 242 | 0.00 244 | 0.00 241 | 0.00 244 | 0.00 241 | 0.00 239 | 0.00 239 | 0.00 240 | 0.00 240 |
|
testmvs | | | 0.01 235 | 0.02 236 | 0.00 237 | 0.00 242 | 0.00 243 | 0.01 244 | 0.00 239 | 0.01 240 | 0.00 244 | 0.03 240 | 0.00 244 | 0.01 239 | 0.01 238 | 0.01 236 | 0.00 240 | 0.06 238 |
|
test123 | | | 0.01 235 | 0.02 236 | 0.00 237 | 0.00 242 | 0.00 243 | 0.00 245 | 0.00 239 | 0.01 240 | 0.00 244 | 0.04 239 | 0.00 244 | 0.01 239 | 0.00 239 | 0.01 236 | 0.00 240 | 0.07 237 |
|
MTAPA | | | | | | | | | | | 65.14 1 | | 80.20 14 | | | | | |
|
MTMP | | | | | | | | | | | 62.63 11 | | 78.04 21 | | | | | |
|
Patchmatch-RL test | | | | | | | | 1.04 243 | | | | | | | | | | |
|
NP-MVS | | | | | | | | | | 72.00 35 | | | | | | | | |
|
Patchmtry | | | | | | | 47.61 202 | 48.27 179 | 38.86 170 | | 39.59 116 | | | | | | | |
|
DeepMVS_CX | | | | | | | 6.95 241 | 5.98 241 | 2.25 236 | 11.73 238 | 2.07 241 | 11.85 232 | 5.43 239 | 11.75 231 | 11.40 237 | | 8.10 239 | 18.38 235 |
|